The Sectarians in
America: The Jumpers
Leben: a journal of Reformation Life,
Volume 5, Issue 4, Oct-Dec 2009
Review by Andrei Conovaloff,
February 11, 2010.
Warning to writers, editors, journalists,
scholars:
Invite study subjects to proofread your text.
In September 2009, the religious history journal Leben asked (e-mail below) for
images for
an upcoming article about Molokans in Los Angeles. I replied (below)
noting that all "Molokan" congregations in Los Angles are of the Jumper
religion,
provided many references about Molokans, and asked to "proofread
BEFORE
you
publish,
to
reduce
errors",
which
did
not
happen. By not collaborating, a
sloppy article was published.— pay attention writers,
journalists,
scholars,
editors.
By November 1, 2009, the Leben.us website showed the cover of the
October-December issue, listing the article with "Jumprs" mispelled,
which was corrected after I sent a complaint.
The link was posted on Molokane.org and I subscribed online to read the
magazine as advertised, but could not. Then I complained twice (by
e-mail
and phone message) with no response. In January I recieved the next
issue by mail and complained again (4th complaint), and finally got the
issue I wanted,
right. Customer service was poor.
Besides obvious errors, in my opiinion the atricle lacked focus. Below
is the article as published in black font with errors corrected and
comments in red.
With
so
many
blunders
in
this
one
article,
Leben readers
should
check
source
material before relying on other articles.
"Reformation Life" refers to the history of Protestantism. Leben has covered Russia many
times. In it's first year, the third issue of Leben featured "consequences of the religious
wars that devastated Europe, and how God used those horrific events to
send streams of Protestant immigrants into Russia . ..."The
Great
Russian
Trek", "Princess
Palatine
Elizabeth", "Harvest of Sorrow",
and
in
a
later
issue:
"The
Odessa
Church
Today", and Kurt
Snow wrote a brief article about the songbook used by Germans in
Russia: "Wolga
Gesangbuch
-
The
Volga
Hymnal", Leben, 2005 Jul-Sep (v.1, i.3). This
hymnal should be compared with Molokan and Jumper hymns to find any
borrowed songs.
From:
"Kurt
Snow"
<production@leben.us>
Date: Mon, September 14, 2009 4:17 pm
To: administrator@molokane.org
Subject: Use of images for a magazine article
We publish a small, non-profit magazine (1,700 subscribers) about
church history called "Leben: A journal of Reformation Life". Our next
issue will include an article about the Molokans in Los Angeles during
the early 1900s. We are searching for photos, paintings and other
images to help illustrate our article. Would you have any photos that
we might be able to use in our magazine? If so, do you have the image
in a high-resolution format (300 dpi)? We would, of course, credit you
in the article. Thank you for your reply. You may review our magazine
at www.leben.us.
From:
administrator@molokane.org
Sent: Wednesday, September 16, 2009 11:48 PM
To: "Kurt Snow" <production@leben.us>
Subject: Re: Use of images for a magazine article --
Spiritual
Christian Molokans
Kurt:
1. Please let us proofread BEFORE you publish, to reduce errors.
2. Please, do not confuse Molokans with Jumpers. This is the most
common mistake of journalists.
3. All Molokan congregations in the US are near you, in SF and
Sheridan
4. I'd be glad to help if I knew what topics, themes, focus, story
lines you are considering.
5. Most published literature in the US is about LA Jumpers. Did you
study?
6. I have no excellent early photos of LA Jumpers. But, I do have
many color photos of current buildings, the UMCA Heritage Room
museum-bookstore, the UMCA picnic, ... which have not been posted.
7. I looked at your web site and find you wrote about the Germans
from Russia Volga Hymnal. We also have songbooks with many borrowed
songs (no notes) and would like a music expert to compare melodies and
verses. See. MHC Volume
IV The Origins of Molokan
Singing, By Dr. Linda O'Brien-Rothe. 60 page book and 45 minute
tape.
Taped and musically notated examples show how Molokans [Jumpers]
borrowed melodied from old Russian village folk songs. Proofread by
over 70 Jumpers. http://www.molokane.org/HRSSRS/index.htm#MHC
8. This should be enough to keep you busy.
Andrei
623-466-6282
|
The
Sectarians in
America: The Jumpers
Click on images to read
scanned pages 9, 10, 18, and 19, from Leben,
Vol.
5.4,
Oct-Dec
2009.
[This article appears to have been
quicly written by one person and quickly edited by another, with
neither doing much fact checking. Some topics are over reported, like the
neighborhood location which could be better explained with a map. Other
parts are scant, like the description of the prayer service; or
omitted, like diet, pacifism, . The most
obvious blunder is
showing www.molokanS.org 3
times on photo credits, instead of www.molokanE.org. References for 3
editorial comments are lacking. Whether Doukhbors are actually in
"Gand Junction" without a state (Colorado?), was not checked. It should
be "Grand Forks, B.C." Since this series is
about "Sectarians in America", the sects of Molokans, Doukhboors and
Sabbatarians would be much better covered in separate articles, or in
one
article about Russian "Spiritual Christians" in America. The
distinction between Jumper and Molokan sects is not clear and the terms
used as synonyms. The history of Jumpers is scant. More source
material and notes should have been cited, as in Scott's: "The Pilgrims of
Russian-town
Seventy Years Later." More
comments follow in the article
below and at the end.]
American Christianity has influenced, and been influenced by, a
stunning panoply of non-conformist groups, separatist enclaves and, in
some cases, self-styled prophets and messiahs. In our series "The
Sectarians," we will trace the origins, the beliefs and the impact
which some of these groups have had on the Church today. We begin the
series with a fascinating report we've recently discovered written in
1918 about a group known as the "Jumpers," or "Molokans," (the former
name referring specifically to an 1830's offshoot of the Molokans).
Impelled by the utterances of a prophet-child, they left their native
Russia by the thousands and headed for the "City of the Angels" — Los
Angeles, California.
[Adapted] from The Russians
in Los Angeles by Lillian Sokoloff, A.B., 1918 [The reader should study Sokoloff's
18-page paper. Her data shows that 94% were Jumpers in Los
Angeles,
not Molokans by religion. The Leben editors omitted this fact which
will mislead readers. Though Sokoloff notes these early Russian
immigrants were a mixture of historically related sects, she missed the
Armenian Jumpers, and failed to discern among Jumpers, Molokans, and
New Isreal which were lumped together.]
The first group of [Jumpers]
Molokans, who came here in 1905
[some date this as 1904, Ed.], settled around Bethlehem Institute on
Vignes Street. When others came, a few bought homes along Clarence and
Utah Streets [The
Flats]. Then the
settlement grew in the district situated between
Boyle Avenue on the east and the Los Angeles River on the west, and
between Aliso Street on the north and Seventh Street on the south.
Recently there has been a new settlement made along what is known as
Salt Lake Terrace several blocks east of the larger colony. On that
street are located many of the somewhat better homes. In a hollow south
of Stephenson Avenue and east of Mott Street, there is a group of about
sixty houses occupied by Russians only [Karakala].
[In the photo right showing
relatives who scouted North America for immigration sites, Vasili
(William)
Halopoff
was the first and only Molokan know to have enlisted
in the Canadian Expeditionary Forces (army) in World War One. He
was
reported missing
in
action December 10, 1917. Though claiming to be pacifists, more
Jumpers and Molokans enlisted in WWII than
registered as Conscientious Objectors (but about half served as
non-combatants), and Jumpers who avoided the military furing WWII by
performing Alternate Service in CO camps, failed pay the nearly half
(46%) of their camp fees, defaulting on
$17,000 in debt in 1944. No serious effort has been made to
reimburse the Society of Friends
(Quakers) and Mennonites
who opeared the camps.]
Sectarian Emigration from Russia.
To understand the Russians in Los Angeles, it is
necessary
to consider briefly their historical backgrounds. During the reign of
Alexis Michaelovitch, second ruler of the Romanoff family — 1645-1676 —
Nicon [Nikon], at that time patriarch of the
Russian Greek-Catholic
Church, investigated and decided to change the liturgy. While the
ruling house accepted these changes and formally adopted this type of
worship as the stat religion, there were many dissenters who would not
submit to the dictates of the government in matters of religion. The
dissenters were continually presecuted or banished, and were greatly
disstisatisfied with the bureaucratic institutions, with the hypocrisy
of the priesthood, and with the forms of their worship, the numbers who
sought other types of relition that would satisfy their deep religioous
feelings constantly grew.
Prominent among the religious sects that developed, were the Dukhobors [Doukhobors], the
Molokans, and the Subotniks [Subbotniks].
The
last-mentioned
are
Russians
who
have
embraced
the
Jewish
faith.
This
result
was
not through influence exerted on the part of Jews,
however, because the Jews do not have any form of mission work for the
purpose of conversion to judaism, nor were there any Jews living in
that part of Russia where these religious sects developed. The
Subbotniks embraced judaism as a result of reading the Old Testament.
The essence of the Doukhobor religion is a belief in
the divinity of Christ [this is contrary to modern sources, Ed.], and
the brotherhood of man. The Dukhobors do not believe in any earthly
representative of God; they have no church leaders, and no icons or
images. They do not have church ceremonies nor do they believe in
saints as do the Greek Catholics. They are opposed to war and therefore
to military service. Their religion forbids their indulging in the use
of intoxicating liquors, and in smoking.
[A photo of Molokans in San
Francisco should not be in an article about Jumpers in Los Angeles.]
The name "Molokan, derived from the word "moloko" which means milk, was
first applied to them in 1765 by a religious sect in the Government of
Tambov. This name was applied because of the fact that the Molokans
drink milk every day in the week, while the Greek Catholics abstain
from it on Wednesdays and Fridays, which are fast days for them.
The Molokans had no definite form of religion for many years. During
the last Years of the seventeenth century, two highly educated men,
Skovoroda and Tveritinoff, had come under the influence of the
teachings of Luther, calvin, and other European reformers. These
men then preached reform among the dissenters of the Russian
Greek-Catholic Church. They thus paved the waY for other reformers. For
about one hundred years, the Molokans were unmolested by the
governmental authorities.
It
was
not
long,
however,
before
the
Russian
government
again
began
to
oppress
the
sectarians in various ways. The heavy taxation of their
land proved to be a greater burden than they could possibly bear. They
were again compelled to serve in the army. Some of the more educated
among them foresaw disastrous times because of inevitable wars in which
Russia was to engage. They therefore began to consider the advisabilty
of emigration from their country. It is well known that of the
emigrants from Russia up to the end of the last century, the greatest
number were Jews and a smaller per cent were Poles, but scarcely any
Russians proper. In the last two years of the nineteenth century, many
of the Dukhobors left the Caucasus region and went to Western Canada
where several thousands now live. [There remains a large community in
the Grand Junction [Grand
Forks,
British Columbia] area, Ed.]
[The Shubin congregation
(photo right) is the most extreme Maksimist of all Jumper congregations
in America. The photo was taken in the "Flats", on
Clarence
Street,
south
of
First
Street.]
The beginning of the Russo-Japanese War inaugurated a new era of
persecutions for the sectarians in southeastern Russia. They were
compelled to go to war. Though many were capable of occupying high
military positions, they were prevented from so doing and were put to
the most menial work. They also suffered all kinds of insults at the
instigation of government officials. They were not permitted to go
anywhere without passports — and passports were not granted them. It is
therefore not surprising that these people became disgusted with
conditions such as they experienced, and longed to leave the country.
Occupations
Of all the Russians in this city, about 75
per cent of the working men were employed in lumber yards up to the
outbreak of the war. Then the majority entered the ship-building
industry. About 10 per cent own and drive their own teams, and work by
the day in hauling produce and other commodities. About 2 per cent are
engaged in running little grocery stores and butcher shops, which are
patronized by their own people. The remainder — about 13 per cent — are
employed in various ways, e. g., in the metal trades, automobile shops,
planing mills, fruit canneries. The last-mentioned occupations are
followed by the younger men of the community, who have had some
schooling but who left school as soon as the law permitted them to do
so.
It is the usual thing among the Russians for the married women to work.
The young women are employed chiefly in laundries. Girls who have
attended school and have learned the English language, work in the
biscuit factories which are in the neighborhood. A small number of
girls work in a candy factory on Utah Street. The older women work in
fruit canneries or do housework by the day. Though many of the girls
who have been to school for several years, could do other work and
perhaps earn more money, the parents are anxious to have them work near
home and among their own people. Clerking or office work might cause
the girls to become "Americanized" quickly and to this the older people
object.
The religion of the Molokans sprang from that of the Dukhobors. Both
these sects are opposed to war. They believe in no earthly
representatives of God. The Molokans have no ministers or church
dignitaries of any kind. They have no rules or traditions as to who
shall be their religious advisers. Their pastors are not ordained, do
not receive compensation, and are not dependent upon the approval of
the community. Their authority prevails only at prayer meetings,
marriage ceremonies, and funeral services. It may be said that the
Molokan religion has little definite form. It is systemless. Many of
its phases are exceedingly crude. It is incoherent and inconsistent.
Like the orthodox Jews, the Molokans abstain from eating pork and are
supposed to slaughter their beef in a certain manner.
There are at present seven churches in the Russian settlement. These
are simply very large rooms in which church services are conducted.
During holidays, some private homes are also used for religious
services. The Priguni [Pryguny =
Jumpers in Russian] conduct their prayers in a unique manner.
All pray aloud for some time, until one feels that the "spirit" has
entered into him, when in a trance-like manner he comes to the center
of the place of worship. The praying goes on in a sing-song loud tone
of voice until one by one, every person feels the "spirit" within
him....
Abridged from: Studies in Sociology, SOCIOLOGICAL MONOGRAPH NO. 11.
Vol. III MARCH 1918 No. 3. EDITED BY EMORY S. BOGARDUS, Department of
Sociology. University of Southern California, Originally published by
the University of Southern California Press. Los Angeles, California.
For the complete text, please visit:
http://www.archive.org/stream/russiansinlosang0lso
ko/russiansinlosang01soko_dj vu.txt [The complete origiinal 1918 document
is
online
in
6
formats
on
the
Text
Archive, and on Google Books in Sociology and social research, Volumes 1-5.]
While there are still numerous groups in
the U.S. and in Canada that are direct descendants of the Molokan and
Doukhabor [Doukhobor]
sects, their influence may well have been enormous on what is today
generally referred to as Pentecostalism.
The Molokans, especially of the "Jumper" variety, had a
long history of laying claim to modern-day manifestations of the
apostolic gifts, including healings, tongues, etc. When they
moved to Los Angeles, California, most settled near the lumber yard
that employed many of the men, a lumbar yard situated in close
proximity to Azusa Street. A year after the Molokans [Jumpers] arrived, the
"Azusa Street Revival", considered by many to be the birthplace of
American Pentecostalism, burst forth into the American church scene.
The "revival" continued with three services a day for nearyly three
years.
It is an established fact that many of the Russian Molokans [Jumpers] became a
part of the Azusa Street Revival, but it remains a mystery as to
whether they were converts or, after a fashion, the founders.
- The proper historical label
of "Spiritual Christian Jumpers"
was never used in this article.
- The photo (above) of the
"world-wide Molokan Center" is outside the theme, mislabled, and
misleading. This Russian Molokan
organization is called Союз духовных
христиан—молокан
(СДКМ, website: SDKM.ru), Souiz
dukhovnykh kristiane—molokan, Union
of
Spiritual Christian Molokans (USCM) — the "Molokan Center" in
short. American
Jumper-S&L-users, the subject of this article, do not support
or recognize Russian Molokans, and generally consider themselves
spiritually superior to Molokans. Many other photos of
Jumper-S&L-users in the Former Soviet Union could have been used,
to not confuse the two sects.
- The reader would probably
want to know more about the "apostolic gifts"
which are merely mentioned in this summary, yet this is outside of
Sokoloff's paper and appears at the end, like a teaser.
- Documentation of Jumpers
attending the Azusa
Street Revival
are scant (4 count), and should be another article.
- The conclusion that
American Jumpers were "converts" to the Azusa
Street Revival
may apply only to the Armenian-Jumpers,
because
they
adapted
the
label
Pentecosts,
and
indirectly
to
many
individual
Jumpers
who abandoned
their Russian religious heritage, ethnic labels, and avoided the
zealous and uneducated to intermarry and/or melt into
America and English-speaking churches. Some changed their Russian last
name. Many chose American churches with a similar Protestant theology,
like Vineyard, EV Free, .... More than half (estimates up
to 90%) of the descendants of Jumpers and Molokans in America have
joined or primarily attend other faith churches. Some are duo-faith —
paying dues in a Jumper-S&L-user congregation and/or cemetery, while
attending (even baptized in) an American church. Faking alliance with
the Jumpers
allows one to avoid discrimination by zealous Jumpers while
participating in family
Jumper religious events, like funerals, weddings, and holidays. One
Vineyard
church
in
Whittier,
California,
reportedly
had
as
many
as
40%
of
its attendance from descendants of Jumpers. Conversion of sectarian
descendants should be another article.
- There has never been any
previous suggestion or documentation that Jumpers were the "founders"
of American Pentecostalism or that their "influence ... [was] enormous
... [on] ... Pentecostalism" as stated in the article, though many
joined and contributed. A well-known example is Demos Shakarian,
who
descended
from
Armenian-Jumpers,
founded
the
Full Gospel
Business Men's
Fellowship International (FGBMFI), and publishing the best-seller: The Happiest People on Earth.
Several lesser renown Jumper descendants have become ministers in
new-world congregations (John Michael Novikoff, David Joseph Shinen),
and many have taken leadership positions (deacons, board members,
teachers, newsletter editors, financial supporters, and missionaries).
|